Find Rentals
Popular Cars
Rental Deals
Insights
Agencies
FAQs
Water Island

Cheap Car Rentals in Water Island, Saint Thomas Island from C$ 36

Driver's age: 25-65
Here’s why our users search for rental cars through Cheapflights

Save over 47%Compare Cheapflights against other travel sites with one search.

Price trackingHolding out for a great deal? Get notified when prices are reduced.

Customized resultsFilter by rental agency, car type, price range and more.

Unlimited free useSearch as many times as you want with no hidden charges or fees.

Water Island, Saint Thomas Island car rentals in 2026

Most popular company

Dollar

Most common car type

Economy

Average price per day

C$ 88

Cheapest price per day

C$ 36
Search Deals
Search Deals
Search Deals
Search Deals

Popular car types in Water Island, Saint Thomas Island

All deals
Economy

Economy

C$ 41+

View deal
Compact

Compact

C$ 40+

View deal
Standard

Standard

C$ 50+

View deal
SUV

SUV

C$ 104+

View deal
Minivan

Minivan

C$ 88+

View deal
Full-size SUV

Full-size SUV

C$ 99+

View deal
Premium SUV

Premium SUV

C$ 129+

View deal
Compact SUV

Compact SUV

C$ 46+

View deal

Best Water Island, Saint Thomas Island car rental deals

Nissan VersaC$ 40/day
Nissan Versa
Found 10/23/26
Nissan VersaC$ 36/day
Nissan Versa
Found 10/23/26
Ford ExpeditionC$ 91/day
Ford Expedition
Found 10/24/26

Cheapflights insights for Water Island car rentals

Get relevant, data-driven information to help you rent a car in Water Island, including pricing trends, ideal booking times, and more.

How far in advance should I rent a car in Water Island?

For the best savings on car rentals in Water Island, make your reservation 8 days before pickup. The average price then is just C$ 70/day – about 21% less than the yearly average.

Find deals

What is the cheapest rental car company in Water Island?

Alamo is currently the cheapest rental car company in Water Island with deals as low as C$ 39.46/day found in the past two weeks. Budget is another inexpensive option with rates as low as C$ 41.74/day.

What is the best car rental company in Water Island?

Based on Cheapflights user feedback, the highest-rated car rental company in Water Island is Budget (rated 6.1/10 with 42 reviews). National (rated 10.0/10 with 1 review) is also highly rated by our users.

Budget
Budget
6.1
National
National
10.0
Alamo
Alamo
9.0
Ace
Ace
7.5

What is the cheapest month to rent a car in Water Island?

Planning a car rental in Water Island? September is the cheapest month, costing about C$ 60 per day. In contrast, February is the most expensive, with an average daily rate of C$ 97. Monthly average rental prices are listed below. Remember, prices can change based on when you book, the type of car, and availability.

January

C$ 91

February

C$ 97

March

C$ 90

April

C$ 90

May

C$ 85

June

C$ 85

July

C$ 88

August

C$ 74

September

C$ 60

October

C$ 62

November

C$ 63

December

C$ 91

Find deals

Top rental agencies in Water Island, Saint Thomas Island

Budget

6.1
Okay
42 reviews•2 locations
Check prices
Overview

Cleanliness

6.8

Comfort

7.2

Overall

6.1

Pick-up/drop-off

6.2

Value

6.0

National

10.0
Wonderful
1 review•1 location
Check prices
Overview

Cleanliness

10.0

Comfort

10.0

Overall

10.0

Pick-up/drop-off

10.0

Value

10.0

Alamo

9.0
Wonderful
1 review•1 location
Check prices
Overview

Cleanliness

10.0

Comfort

9.0

Overall

9.0

Pick-up/drop-off

10.0

Value

9.0

Ace

1 location
Check prices
Overview

Cleanliness

7.2

Comfort

7.8

Overall

7.5

Pick-up/drop-off

7.0

Value

7.2

Dollar

6.4
Okay
3 reviews•1 location
Check prices
Overview

Cleanliness

6.9

Comfort

7.0

Overall

6.4

Pick-up/drop-off

6.9

Value

6.3

Hertz

4.3
Mediocre
11 reviews•1 location
Check prices
Overview

Cleanliness

6.5

Comfort

6.1

Overall

4.3

Pick-up/drop-off

4.8

Value

3.8

Enterprise Rent-A-Car

1 location
Check prices

Apex

1 location
Check prices

Water Island Car rental FAQs

  • Can I rent a car for a month at Water Island?

    The length of time you can book a rental for is subject to the inventory of the supplier. When renting a vehicle from Water Island it should be possible to rent a car for a whole month if needed.

Browse thousands of different options on Cheapflights for your next trip

Airport car rentals in Saint Thomas Island

Saint Thomas Island Cyril E King Airport car rentals
Christiansted Henry Rohlsen Airport car rentals

Best Car Rental Deals

We make it easy and fast to find and compare deals from 70,000+ rental locations and hundreds of agencies.

No Surprises

Prices shown to you will be completely in full, without any hidden charges or fees.

Free Cancellation

Plans change — we get it. And that’s why you can search and book rental cars on Cheapflights from agencies that offer free cancellation