Find Rentals
Popular Cars
Rental Deals
Insights
Agencies
FAQs
Randalls and Wards Islands

Cheap Car Rentals in Randalls and Wards Islands, New York from C$ 44

Driver's age: 25-65
Here’s why our users search for rental cars through Cheapflights

Save over 47%Compare Cheapflights against other travel sites with one search.

Price trackingHolding out for a great deal? Get notified when prices are reduced.

Customized resultsFilter by rental agency, car type, price range and more.

Unlimited free useSearch as many times as you want with no hidden charges or fees.

Randalls and Wards Islands, New York car rentals in 2026

Most popular company

Ace

Most common car type

SUV

Average price per day

C$ 92

Cheapest price per day

C$ 44
Search Deals
Search Deals
Search Deals
Search Deals

Popular car types in Randalls and Wards Islands, New York

All deals
Economy

Economy

C$ 59+

View deal
Compact

Compact

C$ 47+

View deal
Intermediate

Intermediate

C$ 50+

View deal
Standard

Standard

C$ 63+

View deal
Minivan

Minivan

C$ 63+

View deal
Full-size SUV

Full-size SUV

C$ 81+

View deal
Premium SUV

Premium SUV

C$ 110+

View deal
Intermediate SUV

Intermediate SUV

C$ 50+

View deal

Best Randalls and Wards Islands, New York car rental deals

Ford ExplorerC$ 63/day
Ford Explorer
Found 10/30/26
Kia ForteC$ 50/day
Kia Forte
Found 10/30/26
Class VehicleC$ 51/day
Class Vehicle
Found 10/31/26

Cheapflights insights for Randalls and Wards Islands car rentals

Get relevant, data-driven information to help you rent a car in Randalls and Wards Islands, including pricing trends, ideal booking times, and more.

How far in advance should I rent a car in Randalls and Wards Islands?

For the best savings on car rentals in Randalls and Wards Islands, make your reservation 7 days before pickup. The average price then is just C$ 61/day – about 6% less than the yearly average.

Find deals

What is the cheapest rental car company in Randalls and Wards Islands?

Payless is currently the cheapest rental car company in Randalls and Wards Islands with deals as low as C$ 29.78/day found in the past two weeks. Ace is another inexpensive option with rates as low as C$ 33.35/day.

What is the best car rental company in Randalls and Wards Islands?

Based on Cheapflights user feedback, the highest-rated car rental company in Randalls and Wards Islands is Sixt (rated 6.6/10 with 37 reviews). Hertz (rated 6.2/10 with 41 reviews) is also highly rated by our users.

Sixt
Sixt
6.6
Hertz
Hertz
6.2
Budget
Budget
5.7
Ace
Ace
4.4

What is the cheapest month to rent a car in Randalls and Wards Islands?

The cheapest month to rent a car in Randalls and Wards Islands is January, when you can expect to pay C$ 59/day on average. The most expensive month to rent a car in Randalls and Wards Islands is July (C$ 133/day on average). The average daily rental price for each month is shown below. Keep in mind that prices will vary based on availability, when you book, and the type of car you rent.

January

C$ 59

February

C$ 64

March

C$ 73

April

C$ 81

May

C$ 88

June

C$ 119

July

C$ 133

August

C$ 117

September

C$ 85

October

C$ 99

November

C$ 84

December

C$ 84

Find deals

Top rental agencies in Randalls and Wards Islands, New York

Sixt

6.6
Okay
37 reviews•1 location
Check prices
Overview

Cleanliness

7.1

Comfort

7.2

Overall

6.6

Pick-up/drop-off

6.5

Value

6.5

Hertz

6.2
Okay
41 reviews•2 locations
Check prices
Overview

Cleanliness

7.0

Comfort

6.9

Overall

6.2

Pick-up/drop-off

6.1

Value

6.1

Budget

5.7
Fair
94 reviews•1 location
Check prices
Overview

Cleanliness

6.7

Comfort

6.6

Overall

5.7

Pick-up/drop-off

5.6

Value

6.0

Ace

4.4
Mediocre
74 reviews•1 location
Check prices
Overview

Cleanliness

5.5

Comfort

5.3

Overall

4.4

Pick-up/drop-off

4.7

Value

4.6

Advantage

1 location
Check prices
Overview

Cleanliness

10.0

Comfort

10.0

Overall

10.0

Pick-up/drop-off

10.0

Value

10.0

Enterprise Rent-A-Car

1 location
Check prices
Overview

Cleanliness

8.3

Comfort

8.2

Overall

8.2

Pick-up/drop-off

8.3

Value

7.8

Payless

7.3
Good
15 reviews•1 location
Check prices
Overview

Cleanliness

7.6

Comfort

7.5

Overall

7.3

Pick-up/drop-off

7.2

Value

7.4

Dollar

5.0
Fair
21 reviews•1 location
Check prices
Overview

Cleanliness

6.2

Comfort

6.1

Overall

5.0

Pick-up/drop-off

5.1

Value

5.0

Randalls and Wards Islands Car rental FAQs

  • Can I rent a car for a month at Randalls and Wards Islands?

    Yes, renting a vehicle at Randalls and Wards Islands for a month is certainly possible.

  • What is the cheapest rental car in Randalls and Wards Islands, New York?

    Hyundai Accent is the cheapest rental car in Randalls and Wards Islands, New York at an average cost of C$ 43 per day. C$ 43 per day is 28% cheaper than what other rentals cost in Randalls and Wards Islands.

  • How much is a rental car in Randalls and Wards Islands, New York?

    Rental car prices in Randalls and Wards Islands, New York will vary depending on when you book, but at the moment you can expect a rental to cost C$ 43 per day on average and as low as C$ 44 per day.

Car rentals by fuel type in Randalls and Wards Islands

All deals

Browse through car rental deals by fuel type in Randalls and Wards Islands. There are currently 3 fuel types to choose from with Electric being the cheapest (C$ 43+).

Electric

Electric

C$ 43+

View deal
Gas/Diesel

Gas/Diesel

C$ 51+

View deal
Hybrid

Hybrid

C$ 45+

View deal

Browse thousands of different options on Cheapflights for your next trip

Airport car rentals in New York

New York John F Kennedy Intl Airport car rentals
Newark Airport car rentals
New York LaGuardia Airport car rentals

Best Car Rental Deals

We make it easy and fast to find and compare deals from 70,000+ rental locations and hundreds of agencies.

No Surprises

Prices shown to you will be completely in full, without any hidden charges or fees.

Free Cancellation

Plans change — we get it. And that’s why you can search and book rental cars on Cheapflights from agencies that offer free cancellation