Cheap Car Rentals in New York, NY from C$ 42
This price is the cheapest per day rate found by a Cheapflights user in the last 48 hours by searching for a car rental in New York with a pick-up date of 9/11 and drop-off date of 23/11. Fares are subject to change and may not be available at all agencies or on all dates of rental. Click the price to replicate the search for this deal.
Here’s why our users search for rental cars through Cheapflights
New York, NY car rentals in 2026
Get helpful information to start your search for the perfect car rental in New York, NY. The average price data is based on the last 12 months and was last updated on 10 October 2026.
Most popular company | PAYLESS |
|---|---|
Price of gas per litre | C$ 1.84 |
Average price per day | C$ 117 |
Cheapest price per day | C$ 42 |
Popular car types in New York, NY
Explore the most popular car models available for rent in New York, NY and choose the one that suits your needs. The price data is sourced from various car rental companies and was last updated on 10 October 2026.
small car is the cheapest car type you can rent in New York this past week from 156 rental locations out of 42 rental agencies. Prices for a New York small car rental start from C$ 42/day. Check out available deals for 5 car types currently offered at listed car rental agencies here:
Economy
C$ 42+
Compact
C$ 44+
Intermediate
C$ 50+
Standard
C$ 61+
Full-size
C$ 51+
Minivan
C$ 64+
Premium
C$ 67+
Premium SUV
C$ 112+
Best car rental deals found in New York
Browse through a selection of recently found affordable car rental deals in New York, NY. Plan your trip with ease and find the perfect rental option for your needs. There are currently 8 rental car agencies in New York, NY with an average daily rate of C$ 59. Data was last updated on 10 October 2026.
Toyota YarisC$ 42/day
Toyota CorollaC$ 44/day
Class VehicleC$ 50/day
Cheapflights insights for New York car rentals
Get relevant, data-driven information to help you rent a car in New York, including pricing trends, ideal booking times, and more.
How far in advance should I rent a car in New York?
For the best savings on car rentals in New York, make your reservation 7 days before pickup. The average price then is just C$ 84/day – about 13% less than the yearly average.
What is the cheapest rental car company in New York?
In New York, the most affordable rental car company right now is Ace Rent-a-Car, offering prices from just C$ 29.68/day over the past two weeks. Another budget-friendly choice is Ace, with rates starting at C$ 34.78/day.
What is the best car rental company in New York?
Based on Cheapflights user feedback, the highest-rated car rental company in New York is Avis (rated 6.8/10 with 143 reviews). Thrifty (rated 5.0/10 with 55 reviews) is also highly rated by our users.
What is the cheapest month to rent a car in New York?
At New York, the best time to rent a car is in January, with an average daily rate of just C$ 73. Conversely, July is the priciest month, averaging C$ 148 per day. Below youll find the monthly average rental prices. Note that costs can fluctuate depending on availability, booking time, and vehicle type.|1#In New York, the best time to rent a car is in January, with an average daily rate of just C$ 73. Conversely, July is the priciest month, averaging C$ 148 per day. Below youll find the monthly average rental prices. Note that costs can fluctuate depending on availability, booking time, and vehicle type.
January
C$ 73
February
C$ 80
March
C$ 90
April
C$ 100
May
C$ 111
June
C$ 131
July
C$ 148
August
C$ 135
September
C$ 105
October
C$ 95
November
C$ 97
December
C$ 105
What car do most people rent in New York?
SUV rentals (Chevrolet Equinox or similar) are the most popular option for those visiting New York. Passenger Van rentals (Toyota Sienna or similar) are also a popular choice, followed by Intermediate rentals (Toyota Corolla or similar).
Which car rental company has the most locations in New York?
Avis has 13 locations throughout the area, more than any other company. AAMCAR has the second-highest number of locations in New York at 2.
Top rental agencies in New York, NY
Explore the leading car rental agencies in New York, NY known for their outstanding service and extensive range of vehicles to choose from. There are currently 8 car rental companies in New York, NY. Reviews were last updated on 10 October 2026.
Overview
Reviews
Locations
Avis
143 reviews•13 locations
Overview
Cleanliness
7.4
Comfort
7.4
Overall
6.8
Pick-up/drop-off
6.8
Value
6.9
Recent reviews
2.0
|Jul 2025I was still charged for my insurance even though I canceled my trip.
4.0
|Jun 2025Car received was dirty inside and out and smelled like marijuana smoke. Had to clean bugs off the windshield at gas station to see. No other options for the vehicle size I needed to had to take it.
10.0
|Sep 2023Avis experience was great. Only discrepancy in the actual bill and ebill sent on email.
8.0
|Sep 2023The car was fantastic. It was bigger than expected and the boot was huge. It made life easier with two special needs children. Staff at the desk could’ve been more friendly.
2.0
|Aug 2023The car was in poor condition. There were pills on the floor near the drivers seat. The sensors are delayed I advised the center to not offer this car to any other patrons. Keep in mind, this wasn't even the car that I originally wanted because of size. So basically, it wasn't what I wanted, it was in poor condition and it drives poorly. Unfortunately, this was an all around bad experience.
10.0
|Jul 2023Pick up in New York was easy and stress free. Drop off at Orlando was algo really easy.
1 out of 48
Overview
Reviews
Locations
Thrifty
55 reviews•6 locations
Overview
Cleanliness
5.7
Comfort
5.7
Overall
5.0
Pick-up/drop-off
5.1
Value
5.1
Recent reviews
2.0
|Feb 2026Getting the car took a LONG time. They took us to the budget desk but only 1 person the manager was able to deal with the thrifty rentals. There was no sign or info so waited in line to be told to go to another desk and wait again. Took a long time. The car didn't have snow tires which I expect in NY in the winter especially with all the snow we have been having. They were polite and friendly but moved very slowly.
2.0
|Aug 2024My first ever experience with thrifty was terrible. I made my reservation online for a 8pm pickup and when I got there the attendant refused to honor or even look at my reservation email. She didn't even check the system and said they were sold out of vehicles. I told her that I was trying to make it home with my wife and two young children. She had no empathy for me. It was as if she didn't even care. I walked over to Avis and they helped me with ease. I was able to make it home and even for half the price. Never will I ever use thrifty again. Avis won my business
2.0
|Sep 2023Very bad. When I arrived at the desk (with a confirmed booking)they told me that they had no cars available. Not able to get a car at thrifty. We went to AVIS for a perfect car at a perfect price.
8.0
|Jul 2022Good experience!
1 out of 19
Thrifty Locations in New York
Overview
Locations
Routes Car & Truck Rentals
4 locations
Routes Car & Truck Rentals Locations in New York
Overview
Reviews
Locations
National
8 reviews•4 locations
Overview
Cleanliness
8.0
Comfort
7.6
Overall
7.6
Pick-up/drop-off
7.6
Value
7.2
Recent reviews
10.0
|Aug 2024I had an incredible experience renting from this National location in NYC. Isaiah and team were friendly, competent, and quick - all the things a local New Yorker values! Highly recommend the W 56th St location. I will be back.
2.0
|Jan 2023Dropped my reservation after calling and confirming it.
10.0
|Dec 2022Customer service was excellent. Easy to pick up rental and staff was courteous.
1 out of 3
Overview
Reviews
Locations
Payless
29 reviews•2 locations
Overview
Cleanliness
7.7
Comfort
7.5
Overall
7.3
Pick-up/drop-off
7.2
Value
7.4
Recent reviews
2.0
|Aug 2024They didn’t have cars available for me and the 13 people in front of me. No communication while we wait for hours
2.0
|Jan 2022The customer service was very poor the car was dirty
6.0
|Jan 2022Improve the check in and the check out !!
6.0
|Dec 2021The service of the staff was ok' however the car that was given to us a disgrace///we received a car with 44.000 miles !!! that was full of scratches - an experience I would like to forget.
10.0
|Nov 2021Thank you for a stress free car rental during the busiest time of the year . I would recommend you to everyone . Valérie Portente :0)
1 out of 10
Payless Locations in New York
Overview
Locations
AAMCAR
2 locations
AAMCAR Locations in New York
Overview
Locations
Drive Tri-State
1 location
Drive Tri-State Locations in New York
Overview
Locations
U-Save
1 location
U-Save Locations in New York
Car rental FAQs
Find answers to frequently asked questions about car rentals in New York, NY, including policies, requirements, and more. FAQs were last updated on 10 October 2026.
What is the cheapest rental car found in New York?
In the past two weeks, Cheapflights users have found many deals under C$ 117/day when booking a rental car in New York. The best deal a user found was for C$ 76/day from Movly, booked on Oct. 3.
How much does it cost to rent a car in New York for a week from Payless?
Payless is one of the top picks in New York. They can have you in a rental car for about C$ 647 per week on average.
Can I rent a car for a month in New York?
Yes, renting a vehicle in New York for a month is certainly possible.
How much does it cost to rent a car in New York for a month?
Generally, a month-long car rental in New York can be found for about C$ 2,775, with the average price for a rental being around C$ 92 a day. Book with Movly, to take advantage of their cheap prices and pay 50% less compared to the average price of car rentals in New York.
How much is a car rental in New York for a weekend?
C$ 89 is typically the average cost for a rental car for the weekend in New York, though this could vary depending on the time of year. If you’re on a budget when travelling to New York, then opt for a Economy rental vehicle - these tend to be the most affordable on weekends. In the month of November, you can expect to find car rental prices on Cheapflights for as low as C$ 68/day.
Car rentals by fuel type in New York, NY
Browse car rentals by fuel type in New York, NY. Currently, Electric cars are the cheapest to rent in New York, NY. Deals were last updated on 10 October 2026.
Browse through car rental deals by fuel type in New York, NY. There are currently 2 fuel types to choose from with Electric being the cheapest (C$ 34+).
Electric
C$ 34+
Gas/Diesel
C$ 45+
Travelling to a place near New York?
Rent a car at New York if you plan to visit one of these locationsJersey City
Brooklyn
Queens
Staten Island
Wayne
North Bergen
Milford
Carteret
Danbury
Westbury
Bronx
Paramus
Hoboken
Hicksville
New Brunswick
East Rutherford
Clifton
South Plainfield
Yonkers
Hackensack
Browse thousands of different options on Cheapflights for your next trip
Toggle through the tabs below to find thousands of options on Cheapflights for your next trip.
Rental Cars at Airports
Rental Cars in Neighbourhoods
Car Rental Agencies
Rental Car Types
Rental Car Brands
Rentals in Other New York State Cities
Car Rentals in Other Cities
Car Rentals Worldwide
Complete your trip
New York State Vacation Packages
Popular cities