New Town

Cheap Car Rentals in New Town, Key West from C$ 161

Driver's age: 25-65
Here’s why our users search for rental cars through Cheapflights

Save over 40%Compare Cheapflights against other travel sites with one search.

Price trackingHolding out for a great deal? Get notified when prices are reduced.

Customized resultsFilter by rental agency, car type, price range and more.

Unlimited free useSearch as many times as you want with no hidden charges or fees.

New Town, Key West car rentals in 2026

Most popular company

Hertz

Most common car type

SUV

Average price per day

C$ 117

Cheapest price per day

C$ 161

Best New Town, Key West car rental deals

Hyundai AccentC$ 201/day
Hyundai Accent
Nissan QashqaiC$ 211/day
Nissan Qashqai
Jeep WranglerC$ 209/day
Jeep Wrangler

Cheapflights insights for New Town car rentals

Get relevant, data-driven information to help you rent a car in New Town, including pricing trends, ideal booking times, and more.

How far in advance should I rent a car in New Town?

To get the best deal on a rental car in New Town, book about 80 days before your trip. At that point, average daily prices are around C$ 78, which is about 10% cheaper than the typical rate.

What is the cheapest rental car company in New Town?

In New Town, the most affordable rental car company right now is Hertz, offering prices from just C$ 38.20/day over the past two weeks. Another budget-friendly choice is Alamo, with rates starting at C$ 52.36/day.

What is the best car rental company in New Town?

Based on Cheapflights user feedback, the highest-rated car rental company in New Town is Alamo (rated 9.2/10 with 4 reviews). Enterprise Rent-A-Car (rated 7.6/10 with 3 reviews) is also highly rated by our users.

What is the cheapest month to rent a car in New Town?

At New Town, the best time to rent a car is in October, with an average daily rate of just C$ 85. Conversely, December is the priciest month, averaging C$ 121 per day. Below youll find the monthly average rental prices. Note that costs can fluctuate depending on availability, booking time, and vehicle type.|1#In New Town, the best time to rent a car is in October, with an average daily rate of just C$ 85. Conversely, December is the priciest month, averaging C$ 121 per day. Below youll find the monthly average rental prices. Note that costs can fluctuate depending on availability, booking time, and vehicle type.

January

C$ 98

February

C$ 105

March

C$ 114

April

C$ 102

May

C$ 91

June

C$ 91

July

C$ 117

August

C$ 95

September

C$ 88

October

C$ 85

November

C$ 100

December

C$ 121

Top rental agencies in New Town, Key West

Alamo

9.2
Wonderful
4 reviews•1 location
Overview

Cleanliness

9.6

Comfort

9.2

Overall

9.2

Pick-up/drop-off

8.0

Value

9.2

Enterprise Rent-A-Car

7.6
Good
3 reviews•1 location
Overview

Cleanliness

7.8

Comfort

8.1

Overall

7.6

Pick-up/drop-off

7.2

Value

7.8

Economy Rent a Car

1 location

Ace

1 location

Hertz

5.7
Fair
13 reviews•1 location
Overview

Cleanliness

6.3

Comfort

6.1

Overall

5.7

Pick-up/drop-off

5.4

Value

5.8

Thrifty

1 location

Free2Move

1 location

National

1 location

New Town Car rental FAQs

  • Can I rent a car for a month at New Town?

    Typically, how long you can rent a car for depends on the inventory of the supplier. For New Town however, it is certainly possible to rent a car for an entire month.

  • What is the cheapest rental car in New Town, Key West?

    At an average cost of C$ 161/day, the cheapest rental car in New Town, Key West is the Hyundai Santa Fe. Based on our data, it’s 24% cheaper to rent a Hyundai Santa Fe compared to other types of rental cars in the neighborhood.

  • How much is a rental car in New Town, Key West?

    At the moment, rental cars cost C$ 161/day on average in New Town, Key West. Recently, users have found prices as low as C$ 161/day.

Car rentals by fuel type in New Town

Browse through car rental deals by fuel type in New Town. There is currently 1 fuel type to choose from.

Hybrid

Hybrid

C$ 160+

Browse thousands of different options on Cheapflights for your next trip

Airport car rentals in Key West

Best Car Rental Deals

We make it easy and fast to find and compare deals from 70,000+ rental locations and hundreds of agencies.

No Surprises

Prices shown to you will be completely in full, without any hidden charges or fees.

Free Cancellation

Plans change — we get it. And that’s why you can search and book rental cars on Cheapflights from agencies that offer free cancellation